Citing Liam Colley’s evidence extensively, the Tribunal dismissed the class representative’s claim in its entirety.
Retained by Linklaters
Background
On 17 November 2026, in a landmark judgment, the UK Competition Appeal Tribunal (the Tribunal) dismissed in its entirety the £2bn opt-out class action brought against Sony Interactive Entertainment. The class representative alleged PlayStation users were harmed because Sony does not permit rival storefronts to sell digital games and add-on content on its consoles, conduct it said was both exclusionary (exclusive dealing, tying, and refusal to supply) and exploitative (excessive and unfair pricing). The Tribunal heard the claim in a ten-week trial that ended in May 2026.
The Tribunal sided with Mr. Colley’s opinions on each of the liability topics.
Competition Economics Expert Testimony
Counsel for Sony retained Liam Colley of Cornerstone Research as the expert economist on both liability (market definition, dominance, exclusionary abuse, and excessive pricing) and quantum (damages). The Tribunal sided with Mr. Colley’s opinions on each of the liability topics. In particular, the Tribunal agreed with Mr. Colley that physical (disc) PlayStation games imposed a significant competitive constraint on digital PlayStation games and on that basis alone rejected the class representative’s proposed market limited solely to digital PlayStation games. The Tribunal also agreed with Mr. Colley that the relevant market should be defined as a broader “systems market” that included both gaming consoles (the primary products) and gaming content (secondary products). Following its conclusions on market definition, the Tribunal found that Sony was not dominant in the relevant market.
The Tribunal also agreed with Mr. Colley that the relevant market should be defined as a broader “systems market.”
The Tribunal went further and agreed with Mr. Colley that even if the class representative were right on market definition, Sony would not have been dominant, that the margin charged by Sony was not excessive and unfair, and that its alleged exclusionary practices did not restrict competition.
Tribunal Judgment
Citing Mr. Colley’s reports extensively throughout its judgment, the Tribunal accepted Mr. Colley’s analysis on each of the four liability topics. The Tribunal dismissed the class representative’s claim in its entirety.